16 Apr 2017 14:33:00
Thats got to be one of the worst penalty decisions av ever seen by officials but what the foock is broony thinking about thatll be him out of both sevco games.


1.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 14:44:31
Brown was daft with challenge but its a yellow for me. Will we appeal it?


2.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 14:51:21
We can appeal it though.


3.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 14:58:49
Totally agree. To be honest, despite all the posession we are not winning well. Since January we don't create as many chances as we should for the amount of possession we have and we always look vulnerable at the back when players run at us. Not over confident about next week. With Brown out it will make it more difficult but was not too sure we are going to win against Rangers before Brown got his marching orders.


4.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 15:08:10
Is the cup game not different?


5.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 15:08:27
That game's cost us big time! Don't understand everyone tip-toeing around the player's blatant cheating, he was diving just as he touched the ball, complete with the head flick back. it's a dive! You don't flick your head and throw your arms in the air if you anticipate being clattered. cheat!

Broony lost any composure he has, can you appeal a straight red?

Hope they go down now.

{Ed001's Note - terrible and embarrassingly shameful dive that was!}


6.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 15:46:59
Who's tip-toeing around it miko? Even Neil McCann said it was blatant cheating. Absolutely disgraceful from the player and the officials. Scott Brown should know better than to dive in at that speed in injury time, he's let us down but luckily we can appeal.


7.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:07:05
@kevbhoy yes it was blatant cheating . Brendan called it correct, put it on camera so as not to be ignored . Will brendan be charged though for his comments 🤔🤔🤔

As for broony! It was a rush of blood to the head . Barry Robson said it looked worse that it was in terms studio. Mind this is the ref who deemed a studded tackle by a Motherwell player on wee tierneys knee cap only a yellow?

The refs are just warming up for the weeks ahead .


8.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:24:28
What you on about Kev? On one hand they're saying he's cheated and they then comment about how he was anticipating contact and he'll be feeling a wee bit guilty. bollocks to that mince! There's no ambiguity, he took a dive, why try to justify his actions?


9.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:26:06
Outrageous decision for the pen. The Premiership could do without Don Robertson for a while. Big let down by Broony too. He's showed real maturity and experience the past few seasons and that was just foolish from him. I've seen yellows given for worse but he gave the ref a decision to make. I'm not a fan of that set up today either. Never been comfortable with three at the back and really don't see the point unless you play with two natural strikers.


10.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 15:54:00
Is it both?


11.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:01:25
@mallythetally - I heard SB doesn't want to be known as part of the side that loses the unbeaten record to Rangers. 😉.


12.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:33:33
Yayo it's a yellow for me as well.


13.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:34:50
If we appeal it he will be able to play on Sunday supposedly.


14.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:42:03
The Honest mistakes are the only thing that will stop the treble! Ref and linesman had a perfect view.


15.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:49:25
He can't be banned in time if we appeal kev. So no doubt we will appeal.


16.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:49:41
. and Scott Brown's not let anyone down, he's been outstanding this season!


17.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 17:02:51
An honest mistake stopped the treble 2 seasons ago and wouldn't surprise me if something similar happens on Sunday. Got to make sure we"re out of sight early on cos i fear if it's tight going into the last 15 mins the honest mistake will happen.


18.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 16:44:25
It is a dive. Its not only cheating Celtic but all of the teams fighting relegation. Dusgrace. Not sure about this but i think if ref sent him off for violent conduct then he can't play in semi. Otherwuse ban kicks in on next league game. Ed will know better than me. What happens Ed?

{Ed007's Note - Appeals have to be made within 2 working days and are normally held on the Thursday but as Monday’s a bank holiday clubs were told in advance that any hearings arising from the weekend’s games would not be heard until April 27 - so if Celtic appeal Brown can play next week and then his case will be heard on the 27th.}


19.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 18:49:07
UJ look forward to speaking next Sunday night ☘️.


20.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 18:56:58
Embarrassing guys. Yes it was a blatant dive but come on, how many times has Dembele done exactly the same thing this season? Whether the referee falls for it or not is irrelevant it's still cheating. On my opinion every player caught diving whether the referee falls for it or not should be given a one match ban. Mind guidetti and his dive last season or Dembele against Dundee and rangers this season.


21.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 18:57:28
Sorry to burst your bubble Union Jack but due to pub hol / red tape SB is free to play :-D.


22.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 19:02:08
Get it done then. After that decision today celtic have every right to work the system to our benefit.


23.) 16 Apr 2017
16 Apr 2017 23:03:01
@stuart ac no way have u seen anything as bad as that
@uj dream on pal and broony will be at hampden next week. oh how your heart must have missed a beat when u thoght hed miss it haha.


24.) 17 Apr 2017
17 Apr 2017 00:20:23
@jfp88 - you know me lose or victorious draw this season I've always came on. 😉
@jb7 - you have to admire Brenda for calling it like it is for the penalty - blatant cheating but does he then not embarrass himself by appealing a definite red for Brown?

P.S. I thought Brown was rank rotten in the last game as he was too interested in off the ball stupidity with Holt so I'm quite glad he will be playing as ever since he's returned for Scotland I think he's went off the boil a wee bit?


25.) 17 Apr 2017
17 Apr 2017 07:06:36
A definite red was it any worse than holts against us or millers 2 footed lunge or wee gurner against hamilton btw none deemed a red but broony sees red.


26.) 17 Apr 2017
17 Apr 2017 12:03:52
Union Jack if you don't think SB will turn up against you after that and sailing close to the brink of being suspended. added he will miss the following two games then you are filed under just another 'silly billy' am afraid. take a ticket and join the queue .

P.S. It's a big queue!


27.) 17 Apr 2017
17 Apr 2017 17:04:46
Mally in my opinion Dembele dive against rangers was equally as bad. Had Celtic been given the penalty there would be the same outrage. Anyway we aren't talking about who's is worse as a dive is a dive. No matter how bad it is If you Cheat to win a penalty or attempt to win a penalty you're as bad as anyone else who tries it which is why in my opinion every player caught doing it should be given a one match ban whether they've been booked for diving during the match or they've managed to con the referee.

Also for all the Celtic fans claiming some sort of bias against your club from officials this season just have a look at some of the decisions that have gone your way. You might not be discussing an unbeaten season had it not been for that awful decision to award you a penalty away in Perth earlier in the season.